صفحه 1:
Creative Problem Solving
Buddy D. Ratner
Based, in part, on: Fogler and LeBlanc,
“Strategies for Creative
Problem Solving,” Prentice Hall, 1995
A set of tools for:
صفحه 2:
The 7 Habits of Highly Successful People
Tt) eile em OO NAM TUM aL ا Looe
1989
bY رک aE} Vd
عاع اللا لاوطا - غ531 عطغ حممء؟ ممع عط عدذأاو يدوألا »
you're going
© List priorities
© Think WIN/WIN
» Understand -- listen, listen, listen / learn, learn,
learn
© Synergize -- make the whole more than the sum of
the parts
CAN Led وروت رد
صفحه 3:
Effective problems solver develop a mind set
of effectiveness
© Physical: exercise, nutrition, stress
management
® Mental: reading. Thinking
© Spiritual: value clarification,
meditation
® Social/Emotional: empathy, self-
esteem
صفحه 4:
A Recommended Approach to Problem
Solving
° Define
© Generate Solutions
©» Decide a course of action
» غ1 غمع جرع اممرا
® Evaluate
صفحه 5:
ا 4 ۱
Two wilderness hikers chanced upon a fierce grizzly
bear.
One of them pulled his running shoes from his pack
and
rapidly laced them up. His companion yelled in
astonishment,
“Are you crazy? You can’t outrun a bear.”
His reply as he took off down the trail,
“| don’t have to outrun the bear.
All | have to do is outrun you.”
Defining the real problem. A difficult task!
تلرزرتله۱
صفحه 6:
Investigate
A Wea was installed in a chemical plant to deliver a
ighly
corrosive solution. After six months, the solution corroded the
flowmeter and the corrosive liquid leaked on the floor. The
plant
0 رای وت روا یت یا هو ک تلاوت »وا - زیر
كلدت
corrosion. An extensive search was carried out, both time-
consuming
and expensive, with no success in finding the perfect
flowmeter.
The real problem is preventing the flowmeter from leaking,
غموام عط
crew finally decided that the flow meter leaks at six months.
ععقامعه
it every four months.
صفحه 7:
"۱7۳۵
The Problem (a “how to”):
® Know about your subject (read, collect data,
think)
© Talk with others, especially experts
© Expose yourself to the problem -- firsthand
2 aa your ترا -- are you sure you’ve
got the problem?
® Should the problem really be solved?
® Gather more information
© Hypothesize -- test the hypothesis
°® Brainstorm -- come up with solution
alternatives
صفحه 8:
Step 1. Collect and analyze information and
+
® Don't jump to conclusion - Start with a
open mind - Look at the big picture
©» Learn as much as you can Determine
what information is missing and what
information is extraneous The information
should be properly organized, analyzed,
and presented Communicate using
drawings, sketches, and graphs Display
numerical or quantitative data graphically
صفحه 9:
Problem Definition Techniques
تیال ote eee Ra ا ات ۱
nea ae CCN I Ce os و ای تست
تن ای ی رل ری ea نت
ات ات
یت
0
.و مقط
ال ا ا ا رز
یت ا ا
Bete es Lg ل ۱
Sa nL rs
Be RU Re eo)
دوم 1
صفحه 10:
Step 2. Talk with people familiar with the
"7۱
۰ جوا وصفاعق ععنصهتو متعقط مطا وصتوجمللمطه عیمقاطه عطا اعهم وصفاهوز
للع تاوتعصة علعق وصتطاعصدهة فصماكمعفصن امد مل نامث صعطتها صمتاهم مله
0
Cetera ent C hates
Here is a problem encountered by a major hotel a number of years
Seen er Mee cena RRO NO
and frequently caused backups in the lobby area.
۱ tic Rawr
of rooms and a significant loss of income.
قط لعصمة صعصد زللقناكةء دمت هكم ة خصوء متف وستعمع طمعنره ,سمسومل عط
SSMS ل was too 1
وحن انیا
۳
تفت ریت۱3
ل یت
صفحه 11:
Step 3. If at all possible, view the problem
first hand
Sates a NAIC eR ce LsEr)
Sonnet Marne a 6ظا که عمهناهاعمعاهز ound
OMSL Naa ee er
کر ار یلیل
product (PVC). The main piece of equipment was a large reactor with a
Coralie La cia taco Ie MITA MNT cota eet tol eae Caterer
wae On
و
When the plant was started up, the plastic was dark, nonuniform, and way
off design specifications.
ل
ea Tae) ا ا
م ا ی بای
M COT ا ل ل
۳
صفحه 12:
Step 4. Confirm all findings
©» Cross check and cross reference data, facts, and figures
Challenge assumptions and assertions
300 وداءء لمعم ele Colm نات یازور
recycling their "cooking" chemicals used in the paper
رورا لباک تیا
After two years, the process had yet to operate correctly.
Courtland Construction was the supplier of the recycling
equipment.
Courtland presented data and information from an article in the
engineering literature that they claimed proved Boxright was not
operating the process correctly.
Rea )1( صا مماغقصعمكصا عتطغ لع لالهمة غطواعلامه8 معطلا
hme) ا ل ا ل ا 5
industrial-size equipment or processes.
صفحه 13:
Problem Definition Techniques
اعدو بتر
222/772
TECHMAMES.
صفحه 14:
۱2
Find out where the problem statement came
۹۹
Let ی
۱ ین
۱ ار یر ار
ار سر یه ره یتست en
هر ame M Ure rite Mectarste(ie te مزه مماغقنغعزه ع0
از ACN Nella eae NOR ZOU Se Rr Mac CTA)
اک یر
The Case of the Dead Fish
* The Situation: "Design a new waste treatment plant to reduce the
"وام اقتصعط 876 درم عغدوي عأكامة
© Who Posed the Problem?
(company upper management's)
رت رس Ce net ae eure ee ۱
(ووع6م علالأد وعم ملعل ما عأموبنا لإمهم مرمع)
ks ل
(company has decided to treat the symptoms)
Has sufficient data been collected? _ ©
ونه وا كعنم ! مبياه كأط 165و علطا كعع مومع أناه)
صفحه 15:
Style 2__ Exploring the Problem
Exploring the Problem
Identify All Available Information
Recall or Learn Pertinent Theories and Fundamentals
Collect Missing Information
Solve a Simplified Version of the Problem to Obtain a "Ballpark"
Answer
and Visualize What Could Be Wrong with the Current ی
Situation
Brainstorm to Guess the Answer
Recall Past or Related Problems and Experiences
Describe or Sketch the Solution in a Qualitative Manner or Sketch
Out a Pathway That Will Lead to the Solution
Collect More Data and Information
After Using Some or All of the Activities Above, Write a Concise
Statement Defining the Real Problem
صفحه 16:
The Case of the Dead Fish
طواع مدهط عطع ٠» Otte
© Our engineer initiates his own investigation
» |dentify Available Information - toxic discharge, river level
low, large number of dead fish_Learn Fundamentals - call
biologist about what could kill fish Missing Information - a
fungus in nearby lakes could kill fish, temperature was
ات high, fish dead a and down the river ott -
ish dying because of fungus not discharge More
Information - an examination of the fish concluded that
any did die of a fungus not the discharge Define the
Problem - Identify ways to cure infected fish and prevent
healthy fish from being infected
صفحه 17:
Style 3 Present State/Desired State
"You can't get there from here"
Present State/Desired State - help us verbalize where we are and
where we want to go. Present State statement should match the
ری ی کر تست یت رت رت رات ار یت ات۱9 Ay
solutions to problems that are not in the Present State
The Situation: "During WWI, a number of aircraft were shot
down over Germany. Many of the planes that made it back
safely to base were riddled with bullet and projectile holes.
Present State Desired State -Many bullets penetrating aircraft
Desired state -Fewer planes shot down
Present State- Many bullets penetrating aircraft
Desired State -Fewer bullet holes
صفحه 18:
Style 4 -The Duncker
Diagram
The Duncker Diagram
The Duncker Diagram points out ways to solve the problem
by making it OK not to reach the desired state. There are
two General Solutions:
1. Solutions that move from the present state to the desired
لت
2. Solutions that modify the desired state until it conforms to
the present state
Functions Solutions are possible Ae to the desired state
Specific Solutions implement the functional solutions
9 ره ا Solutions - What to do. Specific Solutions - How
0 00 6:
صفحه 19:
Duncker Diagram
ی إمنسة بصعت ] مين ماقي
State
Possible Paths to the Desired Stato Possible Paths to Make Prasanl Slate OK
ERE ERP
Solutions to Implement Solutions ها implement Paths
السب ما 7 Maka Present State OK
صفحه 20:
Kindergarten Co
Teaching Is becoming increasingly more difficult
Quit Teaching Make it OK NOT to quit
a ۱
Finda Retire More Leisure Lower Stress
New Job Time Level
CSpecific Solutions) 1 | 1 1
۳ ۲" ۳ 1
Office Substitute Teach Teach Teacha Ghango Stronger
manager teach every hall’ different schools sayin
other term days ~ grade choosing
Gob share) teaching
material
© The real problem was how to lower her
stress at her workplace
صفحه 21:
To Market to Market
Cereal not getting to market fast موی
‘enough to maintain freshness ——
CGShSaSolatiom) Getcereat to market Make it OK for cereal NOT
Seat oe faster to get to market faster
سس گس وود مومس
Build Moro improve Stop Make Corsat Comnce
Pinnts Closer Transporation Making Stay Fresher Customers
Te Market System Cereal Longer That Siightty
Stale Cereal ts
1 ‘Good For You
CSpocitic Sontions) کت
Hire faster Donet Ghanerjets توا .موه
tucksand woay to daliver, chemical tghterand
Tormor race About productto foslowdewn more impor.
cardrvers speed ‘locations the spotling meable to
مج ایا ما reaction فد اد
فال امام ام مهو
صفحه 22:
# 4 Statement-Restatement
© “A problem well-stated is a problem half solved"
Similar to Present State/Desired State Restating the problem is
important to inject ideas
Finat Prooiem Statement
صفحه 23:
Problem Statement Triggers
°© Vary the stress pattern-try placing emphasis on different
words and phrases.
Choose a term that has an explicit definition and substitute
the explicit definition in each place that the term appears.
» Make an opposite statement, change positives to negatives,
and vice versa.
° Change "every" to "some," "always" to "sometimes,"
"sometimes" to "never," and vice versa.
© Replace "persuasive words" in the problem statement such
as "obviously," "clearly," and "certainly" with the argument
it is supposed to be replacing.
©» Express words in the form of an equation or picture, and
۷۱6 ۰
صفحه 24:
Style 5 - The Kepner-Tregoe (K.T.) method
The Kepner-Tregoe (K.T.) method
ace aa رز وا
(رعوعو۲ن) وطنطهز؟ ۰
ame ce aoa ec) ت۱۳
قر ی نت کرت را Cell
High (H); Medium (M); Low (L)
NE as) Oe ee Nees Td
Problem analysis (PA);
۱ را ارت )04(:
Potential Problem analysis (PPA)
:دهع 147 عرمع.
Ed یت 00
دع اكأناوم ادال رت
WS Te Cuter
0
7لع اناما دوين وطلانا
0
#أمغ مومحم غذ كقننا بإطلانا
Why is it unimportant?
ل
صفحه 25:
Key Tricks in Creative Problem Solving
Key Tricks in Creative Problem Solving
۱ tes suk renee neu)
000
Explore alternatives
Cary
- matrix
0 ل Ae CERT rete)
Ue Rel cg feed re eae Rech eestor
ار یرت Coxe lm Maat Lel eo eas)
۱ meee ian)
"نامل لماع أباع8 5
0
Use these tools in any order
0
Does it solve the problem?
Handling criticism
2121 CN eRe eel)