صفحه 1:
صفحه 2:
-EURAMA-
CREATING PERFECT HEALTH
IN EUROPE
THROUGH AYURVEDA
صفحه 3:
OVERVIEW
PRIORITIES - Identifying EURAMA’S strengths & priorities for the
development of Ayurveda in Europe
POLICY - International Policy, EU Policy, EURAMA policy
PRACTICE - Best practice
PARTNERSHIPS - Ayurveda, Modern medicine, Science
POWER - Knowledge is Organizing Power. Generating influence through
vision, knowledge, sattva
EDUCATION - orientation, clinical skills development, professional
training
EVIDENCE - what evidence exists? what evidence is needed? What
evidence can be generated through the EURAMA & the EU in partnership
with centres of excellence in India and globally?
EVALUATION - what is the impact of what EURAMA does? Evaluation for
advancement
صفحه 4:
Ol) Pr ا" Pr
PRIORITIES - EURAMA
@An association for doctors and vaidyas
to maintain an academic framework
@by creating a platform for scientific
research and exchange within the medical
profession,
“thereby ensuring the public and political
acceptance of Ayurveda
as a science and valuable medical practice
@for the individual and society
صفحه 5:
POLICY
صفحه 6:
یی اس و
2 هد OS tac
TEXT VOLUME
ee a oe
صفحه 7:
Utilization of herbal / traditional medicine
D
Level of utilization
Low or insufficient data
ium
High
[J No cata
صفحه 8:
AL: Policy and legislation on TCAM - Global
Status
[No pokey or legistation
[ Lesisiation pending
Legislation only
National poly
[No ata
صفحه 9:
Policy - India & China
<3 INDIA - NATIONAL POLICY
In India, formal recognition for Indian systems of
medicine came with the Indian Medicine Central Council
Act of 1970. In 2002, India developed a specific national
policy to facilitate the integration of these health care
systems into national health programmes. The policy
emphasizes affordability, sarety, efficacy and the
sustainable use of raw materials (Lavekar & Sharma,
5).
CHINA - NATIONAL POLICY
The Government's commitment to “develop modern
medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine” has been
written into the National Constitution and the two are
regarded as of equal importance (Baoyan, 2005).
صفحه 10:
B8: Legal recognition of acupuneturists and practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine
Legal recognition
۳
[es
[No data
صفحه 11:
B4: Legal recognition of Ayurveda practitioners
Legal recognition
۳
ves
[Io data
صفحه 12:
China - India:
differences
© Today acupuncture is a licensed practice in
most industrialised countries & there are
professional bodies, standardised curricula
and regulatory boards for acupuncture in
these countries.
© There are also WHO Guidelines for correct
practice of acupuncture & for research into
acupuncture.
© Similarly, there are WHO standards for safety
and evaluation of Chinese herbal medicines.
صفحه 13:
WHO Support
® There are 7 WHO Collaborating Centres on
TCM in China and 1 in Australia.
® 2 centres in South Korea, 1 in North Korea, 1
in Vietnam, and 2 in Japan are on systems
derived from TCM
# No WHO Collaborating Centres on Ayurveda
or other ISMs
صفحه 14:
What China has done
to promote TCM
© For more than a decade, China has had
a sub-ministry of Traditional Chinese
Medicine (TCM), with ten departments.
4۶ These include departments for
professional licensure, TCM research,
product standards, education etc.
There is an entire department
dedicated to foreign trade in TCM.
صفحه 15:
TCM in the UK
In the UK, every small town can be found to
have a Chinese herbalist shop on its High Street.
These are supplied through Chinese
Government owned or supported TCM herbal
factories & corporations.
Training is provided through Government
colleges, including six full national universities
dedicated exclusively to training in and research
on TCM.
Acupuncture is a licensed profession covered by
the NHS
Chinese herbalism will soon be licensed
صفحه 16:
Africa
@Even in Africa, there is an extensive
network of TCM practitioners offering
services to local Chinese and Western
communities and to more affluent
Africans.
“They import Chinese herbs, which.
represents foreign exchange earnings for
China. Much of this is supported by the
Local Chinese Embassy.
@There are Chinese Government funded
research, education and exchange
programmes.
صفحه 17:
Globalization of Ayurveda
® Has been led by private sector. Began
with MAV, others have followed
® No formal Ayurveda lobby with
governments or WHO
Restrictions on Ayurvedic herbs
No formal licensure of Ayurvedic
practitioners outside South & SE Asia.
® No WHO guidelines on any aspect of
Ayurvedic practice or research
صفحه 18:
Global regulatory status of
Ayurveda
Result:
No internationally accepted Ayurvedic
curriculum
Restrictions on Ayurvedic herbs
No formal licensure of Ayurvedic
practitioners outside the sub-
continent,
“No WHO guidelines on any aspect of
Ayurvedic practice or research
صفحه 19:
Policy on Finance:
Who pays for TCAM?
A very high proportion of TCAM
expenditure throughout the world is
covered by out-of-pocket payments
or private health insurance.
Consistent trend in West towards
utilization by people with a high
disposable income.
صفحه 20:
A2: Public finaneing for TCAM - Global
Status
HE 0 pubic financing
ublicfnancing
Ba
[no data
* Limited public fnance coverage by Medicaid or Medicare
صفحه 21:
EU POLICY on FINANCING
Public health insurance is an important funding
mechanism in Europe, with 22 European
countries offering full or partial reimbursement
for selected TCAM therapies (Burford et al,
2007).
In the United Kingdom in 1995, 40% of GP
practices provided access to CAM, with 10% of
the cost being met by the National Health
Service (Thomas et a/, 2001).
صفحه 22:
US & AUSTRALIAN
POLICY on FINANCING
<8Some American medical insurers confer benefits
for limited complementary medical services,
primarily through eiployer onsored health
plans (Pelletier & Astin, 2002).
In the year 2000, 70% of employee-sponsored
programs covered chiropractic; 17% covered
acupuncture, 12% covered massage, and the
numbers dwindled from there for other CAM
services (White House Commission on CAM
Policy, 2002).
In Australia, since the introduction of a Medicare
rebate for acupuncture in 1984, use of
acupuncture by medical practitioners has
increased greatly. Medicare reimbursements to
doctors for acupuncture rose from $7.7 million to
$17.7 million (Easthope et a/, 1998).
صفحه 23:
Japan & Korea:
POLICY on FINANCING
Since 1976, the Ministry of Health and
Welfare of Japan has approved 147 Kampo
formulations, as well as their individual
herbal components, to be covered by the
national health insurance system.
In the Republic of Korea, national health
insurance has covered traditional
medicine since 1987.
صفحه 24:
TRADITIONAL,
COMPLEMENTARY*AN
ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE
Policy and Public Health Perspectives
Imperial College Press
© Imperial Coll
موس
صفحه 25:
Or arr
PRACTICE
Establish standards of Best Practice for
Ayurveda in Europe.
Draw on Govt of India & All India Ayurveda
Congress standards for clinical practice
Work with medical associations &
regulatory agencies to ensure
acceptability of standards
Address EU’s wellness concerns as well as
medical needs
صفحه 26:
What is wellness?
© Wellness has an emphasis which is quite
distinct from the mainstream health sciences
focus on illness and pathology.
® According to the US National Wellness Institute
(NWI), wellness is: “an active process um through
which people become aware of, and make
choices towards, a more successful existence”.
NWI identifies six dimensions of wellness:
Social; Occupational; Spiritual; Physical;
Emotional; Intellectual.
® LOHAS - Lifestyles of Health And Sustainability
- is a framework that focuses on “health &
Fitness; the environment; personal
development; sustainable living; and social
justice.”
صفحه 27:
Medispas
“A medical spa is a facility whose medical
program is run under the supervision of a
icensed healthcare professional, according
to The International Medical Spa
Association.
“Industry wide recognition of the need to
focus on wellness - need to shift from a
technology-driven industry to one that
focuses on wellness and preventive health.
& Medical Spa Society: Two things are
needed -- a physician on premises actively
involved in the patient's care and a level of
care that will stand up to conventional
scrutiny by accepted standards
صفحه 28:
EVIDENCE BASE
FOR AYURVEDA IN EUROPE
<} PRIORITY DISEASES (Medical perspective). Diseases for which
current conventional treatment regimens are unsatisfactory, e.g.
many cancers and chronic debilitating conditions, for which the
public are turning to Ayurveda & other branches of CM.
<3 PRIORITY POPULATIONS (Public Health Perspective). Also needing
attention are the unmet health needs of ethnic minorities, women,
children, the poor, the elderly and those with special medical
conditions.
4 PARTNERSHIPS FOR RESEARCH CAPACITY BUILDING.
Research database development, coordination, dissemination
artnerships with India’s Golden Triangle Initiative, ICMR, AYUSH
reate WHO Collaborating Centres in Europe for research on Ayurveda
fesearch funding plan for EU
tudent fellowships & research fellowships in Ayurveda
صفحه 29:
Evidence base
in
Asian-themed spas
صفحه 30:
5 Medical Spa Bangkok
صفحه 31:
S Medical Spa, Bangkok
Dr Pakpilai Thavisin, founder director - dermatologist
@ S Medical Spa is a leading & award winning medical
spa in Asia. Offers integrated healthcare service,
combining Eastern traditional healing and spa
therapies plus the modern Western medical science.
@ Classic Spa programmes: spa and relaxation, vitality,
beauty, figure, holistic, and purification
@ Three new programmes:
1. office syndrome: neck, shoulder and back pain as well as
headaches due to working at a computer
2. speedy facial treatment: treatment during lunch
break/after work
3. stress management and sleep medicine: meditation
program to help people suffering from stress and insomnia
صفحه 32:
۳
id /
صفحه 33:
® The Raj, a New York Times & Conde Naste
“best destination’ spa, is an Ayurvedic spa in
Iowa.
# The Raj guests are advised:
‘Lipophilic toxicants (man-made toxins), such as
PCBs, DDEs, DDT and other chemicals and
pesticides tend to accumulate in our fat
tissues. They have been associated with
hormone disruption, immune system
suppression, reproductive disorders, cancer,
and other diseases’ (www.theraj.com)
صفحه 34:
Drawing on published research,
clients at The Raj are informed that
the Ayurvedic programs offered “are
capable of dislodging lipophilic and
other toxins from the tissues and
reducing their concentration in the
body”.
Is this more detail than consumers
want?
The Raj has a high percentage of
repeat guests.
صفحه 35:
e of the Global Spa Industry, 2007
Core Spa Industries $60.31
‘Spa Facility Operations $46.81
‘Spa Capital Investments $12.99
Spa Education $0.31
‘Spo Consulting $0.07
Spa Media, Associations, & Events $0.13
Spa-Branded Products 3
“Spa-Enabled Industries $194.35
Spa-Related Hospitality & Tourism $106.05
ated Real Estate $88.30
0 تنس
صفحه 36:
Pus
Global Market Size (US$ billions)
$500.2
$241.3
$195.8
$162.4
Cone
Beauty and beauty products industry _
Fitness and fitness products industry
Beauty and wellness medicine industry
Healthy foods and nutrition industr
$1,099.7
Total
لا م ل سس
صفحه 37:
[ed انلكا
Estimated Total | FAimeted Total Spa |e imated Total Spa
Number of Spas S$ billions) Employment
Europe 22,607 S184 07
و 21,566 4 363,648
North America 20,662 $135 307,229
Middle Eost-Norh Africa 1014 $07 20,938
Latin America-Coribbean 5,435 $2.5 82,694
‘Arica 389 $0.3 7,273
Total سيك لكك لكك | 1,223,510
صفحه 38:
ee EC ی ی ری OSS TLL)
$60
$150
$80
$27
$21
Core Spa Industries
Commercial Sports Industry?
Golf industry (golf facility operations)! —_
Motion Picture Industry (box office sales)*
Cruise Industry®
صفحه 39:
EDUCATION
4۷ ۲) 32123 مه
Skills development
Full professional accreditation
صفحه 40:
CM Education - EU
“3 The German Federal Chamber of Physicians regulates
postgraduate CM education of physicians, and
medical associations have developed an internationally
standardised postgraduate education.
$3 In the United Kingdom, Curricula for accreditation of
acupuncturists, osteopaths, chiropractors, medical
herbalists have been approved. Short courses in CM are
offered as part of the undergraduate curriculum in all
medical schools, as required by the General Medical
ouncil.
In Hungary, where the practice of therapies such as
homeopa ۷ Ayurveda and traditional Tibetan medicine
is restricted to allopathic physicians, these subjects are
taught in medical universities.
صفحه 41:
CM Education - USA
In the United States and Canada, a growing
number of universities offer continuing
education and elective courses on different CM
therapies.
As of 2005, 98 of the 126 medical schools in
the U.S. included CAM instruction as part of
their required curriculum, as well as a range of
TCAM electives (Brixey et a/, 2005).
صفحه 42:
EVALUATION
Build evaluation into all of EURAMA’s
activities.
What is the impact of EURAMA’s
activities in all of its areas of activity?
What strengths & weaknesses emerge
from evaluation?
@Set & re-set priorities through
evaluation. Evaluate for advancement -
صفحه 43:
What is needed?
A commitment to support the globalization
of Ayurveda in the following ways:
Through development of WHO guidelines
on some of the following areas:
Si curriculum,
"clinical practice of Ayurveda,
83 standards for Ayurvedic herbal preparations,
& panchakarma,
" yoga instruction, etc.
صفحه 44:
National & Regional
Ayurveda Associations
In partnership with the Govt of India:
<3 Develop/adapt Ayurvedic guidelines and
standards,
lobby national EU governments and the EC to
strengthen the development of Ayurveda via
supportive regulations
“Fund & organise conferences that will produce
documents, guidelines, curricula etc that can be
used nationally, regionally and though the WHO
process to establish global standards for a high
level of Ayurvedic practice and regulatory support
صفحه 45:
Or arr
PRIORITIES
ssEURAMA’s focus should vary
according to national need &
regulatory openings.
Adapt EU wide policy goals to
national contexts or EC
programmes.
صفحه 46:
Conclusions
@ Wellness is now a $1trillion industry. The World
Bank estimates it to be a $3 trillion industry by
mid-century
© Within this, Asian healthcare systems &
traditions are globalizing
# Women are leading the trends.
@ The Spa industry is the frontline of Ayurvedic
expansion in the early 21% Century
Evidence of effectiveness & safety are of key
importance to regulators & consumers alike
© EURAMA’s time is here. A focus is needed on
Policy, Practice, Priorities, Education, Evidence,
Evaluation & Power
صفحه 47:
POWER
EURAMA - Generating influence
through
"vision
& knowledge
isattva
Knowledge is Organizing Power
صفحه 48:
4۶] ۳1۸۳1 ۷01
www.giftsofhealth.org