صفحه 1:
Revoxmiica ard Ovatrol
صفحه 2:
SS با
مورا عاهزهه() اموه()
Lifting/Lowering
Pushing/Pulling
Carrying
Weights and Forces
Frequency of activities
Load Center of Gravity
صفحه 3:
SS با
Work Rekied Low Buck Pua (LOP)
© Overexentoa wor clakoed oe he rose oF LBP by aver OO% vk LBP
و
© Du اجره واه منطو HPtcr
© Ove ARK oP Overexention chi volved pushin or pul looks
صفحه 4:
SS با
OSO aires Prow LiPticrey
30% of
Shoulder 22% of
WMSDs Elbow
WMSDs
43% of ۱
Back 13% of
WMSDs Hand/Wrist
WMSDs
Source: SHARP technical report No.
40-6-2002
صفحه 5:
Betwera @Pkysivdl Oork له و(
@uck-Rekted OGOs
Strong Evidence Evidence __ insufficient Evidence
Risk Factor
Lifting/Forceful Movement x
‘Awkward Posture x
Heavy Physical Work x
Whole Body Vibration x
Static Work Posture x
صفحه 6:
SS با
۱69 Risk (Puctors Por Buck
۵۶ یی
* Prequewy
* Poster
* Ousted
صفحه 7:
SS با
®uck رص :اك Risk Puvtor Cxuanvples
صفحه 8:
SS با
®uck رص :اك Risk Puvtor Cxuanvples
0 ۱
6 Deight oP toad
© Lovaive (posiiza oP bod Ww.
0 (requecusy
© @tabth
2 Couptery
صفحه 9:
SS با
© راك حاص Risk Puctor Cxuvples
High Frequency and
Lifting Overhead
صفحه 10:
2 —
8 برص روك حاص Risk Purtor Caccoples
Lifting or Lowering Floor Level Lifting above Shoulder Height
صفحه 11:
! ۲۲۲۲۲"
امسر Por Clues — Ose Ossesowed Took
0 Gucople Ohevhlists
موه و
ساسا هخا و
باسنا" لصت
© 00104910 Dernrd Deseret
Arad Ohechtot
ین هو
ان مه لا و Por
ی
Pubes (PR. Doers)
سوه تاه و .و
سس
REOO— Prickles 0
0 Oudbsis Tools
© Debsites
صفحه 12:
SS با
Look Por Ohes — Geaerd Checklist:
د ادكه Crypurwic Ohevhist Por Outertd Wardiag
Courter: Kodak's Bryparwic Designs Por People of Dork, a ockapted 1 DIOCW
2007-100
صفحه 13:
a
Okechist Por Outerta Wardtay موب 75د ه01
IEPETITION
igh-speed process Tine or war
resentation rates
Similar motions every Tew
seconds
served signs of fatigue
jORKSTATION DESIGN.
ork surface too high or low
‘acation of materials promotes
feaching
;ngleforientation of containers
(
pacing between adjacent
ransfer surfaces promotes
visting
bstructions prevent direct
sccess to load/unioad points
bstacles on floor prevent a
lear path of travel
Toor surfaces are uneven,
ippery, or sloping
joists or other power iting
levices are needed but not
vallable
صفحه 14:
a
21 Cryrurwics Okevhist Por Outertd Woadkog, ovat.
[TENG AND LOWERING:
Heavy objects need to be
andled
Handling bulky or dif cult-t-
rasp objects
Handling above the shoulders
below the knees
ing to the side or
inbalanced iting
acing objects
yccuratelyiprecisel
sudden, jerky movements
juring handling
jne-handed WRG
'ong-duration exertions (stati
york)
USHING/PULLING/CARRYING
‘orceful pushing/puling of
arts or equipment required
rakes for stopping hand
arts/handling aids are
jeeded but not available
arts of equipment desigh
remotes on- neutral
tures
‘ong-distance carrying (earls
jot available)
صفحه 15:
6
ovat. رهبا آمهه() و بططمی() سم ۷) 1)
LONTAINERS/MATERIALS
Lack adequate handles or
ripping surfaces
ve unbalanced, unstable, or
contents shift
structs lag movement when|
eing carried
STHER.
inappropriate work techniques
sed
ulldup of process material
product inereases worker
fort
ersonal protective equipment|
weeded but not available/used
| addup ie
hota! number af Xs
FOTAL SCORE (Optional) identified.
صفحه 16:
SS با
Look Por Ohes — Geaerd Checklist:
O10CW Ouad Odertd Weedicry (DOW) Ckechist
ام سوواط سس اجه و6
صفحه 17:
Ue
Ue
1۳
Ue
Ue
Uw
Ue
۳
Ue
Ue
Ue
Uw
Ue
۲
Ue
Ue
Ue
Ue
Use
Ce
Ue
Ue
Ue
Ue
Ue
Ue
۳
Uw
Ue
Ue
(ee
ew
(ee
Tew
Dee
(he
Ue
Oe
Ue
Tew
9
De
(ee
ee
Dee
De
Dew
Ue
Dee
Oe
Dee
Ube
Oe
ee
Tew
ee
er
Dee
©1001 Dased Dare Labo (OL) hecho
“Oo opens kos pander uk cen ete eka et
(Ore he endeo bea be pp cc by fer hone?
©. Gre cranny mad ver wn deers?
2.6 fre tate he cpt al dbo ont?
©. Ore undone ae
beat?
ee rena?
امه سا di?
موس و
wk?
|
©. re bore habbo beeper?
اوه بش اهوم مات نم
|
|
(40. ve erchoed b wenduanerpuoethe?
(1. Ove #سليصا بمقجي مين ةن تاشحمقن مامد بتع اجيت
(08. one xr enc ad
لحت معنا اميا بجاح لمهم ue sane aah?
۳
‘alee env high?
۳
اس تست
۱
۱
tren?
سیف
۳
(9. Ore puter pl Povo rhe as?
(08. aes fr ean ene verted ao hh tk?
Ce
(8. Ore werk rants cnvethoohay wal Bey nvordees?
صفحه 18:
SS با
Lovk Por Clues — Risk Partor Okevhlsts
AWazed Cudkatos Okechist Por LiPtcg, Cavpies, Pushicy or Put
Gower: TD. R. Oaters, “Oona Datertas Werrdiag”, ta: Physica cond Biological
ان توب the Dorkphice (Geoved ection). Edtied by P. لاه cod B. Grave.
Dew York: doko Diey ord Gras, COO.
صفحه 19:
صفحه 20:
SS با
Lovk Por Clues — Risk Partor Okevhlsts
Oushiyiod Gta دجوو هجو( oF bobor ond ولج — Wazad Low
Ohevhlst Por @uward Postues
Goue:
hip hw. biog! Ook ety! Topics! Breourcics! Sen ices Resvurces!Toos!
صفحه 21:
QOuskiacgiod Gta Oeportect oP bobor ced Tedustries — Wazad Lou
Okevhtst Por @ukward Postues
صفحه 22:
صفحه 23:
Se
2 عصاد اناه Cxervise
" )]( دواو ورج risk Pantors اوتا وجكات حصن
# Ose Ouskigyiva Grate “caloutator to ocr
Lifticey Uobs” to detercotag iP the task is kezardous
صفحه 24:
SS با
C@rioritze obs Por او
¢ 0 Dke Prequeuy und severiy oP the rsh Pastors pou hove
وا لها رو ما لالز cies
۱
سا
۰ و مس له ولو( ot your disposd
٠ deus oP workers Por موه ی
© OR Rivaty ic عمج موم و رومام
© DivePrave Por wohiey ieproveweds
صفحه 25:
SS با
Quke Ikoproveweuts
تمه مس ای بط تم
۱
aay caw risk Pastors thot have aot bora previnsly tected? 09 و
bess وه سا رم مج Por our بوخ Be و
thot cod be equi oP Recive)? مرحم مور
0 PRent prokitvay, ePPiceamy, or product spray?
© Prouile a teeporery or perarnect Pi"?
by ewopbyers...wilt Pet ewer worde? وی و و
مر troicicr) Rr وا ماو Be abe ty be Ply و
تا
صفحه 26:
با کی ۲
Op ربطاه۳)
:صامسم وه مه ۳ ی
۱
ives?
Bera aovepted by workers? و
© Rekiced or eiirated «met or oll oP the risk Pastors?
cew risk Partrs, hazards, or her problews? وه هون و
Oneed a deorecse ia productviy ood PPro? ©
ia product ond service qucity? حول هون .و
© Bera supported wih the tras ceeded tp coke t ehPecive?
صفحه 27:
eee
لا
۱
+ Easier Ways to Manually Lift, Lower, Fill, or
Empty Containers
— Management Guidelines for Safer Lifting
— Employee Guidelines for Safer Lifting
* Easier Ways to Manually Carry Containers
* Alternatives to Manual Handling of Individual
Containers
صفحه 28:
SS با
© ىصوم wprove weuts
٠ loo the workPlow to elcoicate ucoecessary IPs.
+ Orqaaize he work sv tral he physicd dewrouds ood work pare fo euse
ان
۰) the distroces loads ore tPted ord bwered.
+ Postion pol loads oF cotertals of a height that albus workers to KP ord buen
wikia their power ze (Dewees OO to SO inches).
۰ با زاجم لس or bueno loos to or Proc the Poor.
Coweta cary tape or pul
صفحه 29:
صفحه 30:
صفحه 31:
صفحه 32:
Oorkstticd OurO ute
صفحه 33:
Otker Ikoprovewedt Optiows
0 Oushicgiod Grate Ereparwios deo Bock
0 Hip www.kiwe.coulsPeyhopicsireducehzards!
ور rbot Bo da
صفحه 34:
با SS
مهو(
جوا امسوه() امسجی() و Crycwwir Butdehaes
0106۵0 9008۵0
http: WW.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2007-131,
صفحه 35:
! ۳۲۲۲۲۲"
QePerewes
Partre, DIOL Prbkxtra Dv. 8°- U1, 99°. ابا له لت تمالس و
Por Derned Deserted Were, DOO Pubherters Oo. 600۳40 تلف م0 و
e0or.
Ourey, (O99. موه چا اه و
Report PO-O- لمات of Labor nl Ienhores OLOR® و0 سا هه و
e002, e002.
Chrumts of Orem: Prxrare, VIOOW Pdbkeaton Dv. OPAMP, (OOP, 0
DR. Ocery, “Dowrd Detertdb Laudkay!, ko Phyoical ord Dirbted Waar of he 0
by P. Oak xd D. Orve. Dew York: loka Dey xn Ore, لصيل ©) .(دصصطب (Sevared |
6009۰
& ان ام بل Kank’ Orvexwrrts Deoker Por People of Dork, Overnnl Balios, Wobrkew, 0
Onw, Ie., COOP.
Deoksntea Ont Departoest of Labor uc erkotes Drmwics Debote! 0
puis) enh.ep ا hip 0
Cored Dowersyy Breperwiy Debote: و
حت سسحت حا صمو ااانا 6
اون موم( Ora Orerngh Preckstina 90 مات oP تفه و
۱
تا( مرت( ترتع سا ۵
۱
صفحه 36:
"۲۲۲۲۲ !
عاص "1” جو رلك © - 1161 Ter
عا۳) عمرده۲) 2 0
0 M1064 LP icy Cquciod
)او طص اسه و
مانا وخا دسب 0) تسدنا لاساو ها"1” 0019/1/11 2 06
طسو سس و
)ارت مظ) 90 ممطله() اه ممی() ©
میس
۵0۵ اعمس جيجه سسسالاصها و
Okie Grate Lucbar Orica Drier 0
سمل و مسا و
Guovk's Paychophyeticd Dobler 0
© Hip. tiber yrrohisbles. herve tcc! XD _LODPebboetDeb!
rekOrkvardb? wavisna(PekGekvara
Musculoskeletal
Disorders to the
Back
Recognition and Control
Manual Materials Handling
Lifting/Lowering
Pushing/Pulling
Carrying
Weights and Forces
Frequency of activities
Load Center of Gravity
Work Related Low Back Pain (LBP)
Overexertion was claimed as the cause of LBP by over 60% of LBP
patients
Two Thirds of Overexertion claims involved lifting
One fifth of Overexertion claims involved pushing or pulling loads
MSD Injuries from Lifting
30% of
Shoulder
WMSDs
43% of
Back
WMSDs
22% of
Elbow
WMSDs
13% of
Hand/Wrist
WMSDs
Source: SHARP technical report No.
40-6-2002
Evidence for Causal Relationship
Between Physical Work Factors and
Back-Related MSDs
Strong Evidence
Evidence
Insufficient Evidence
Risk Factor
Lifting/Forceful Movement
X
Awkward Posture
X
Heavy Physical Work
X
Whole Body Vibration
Static Work Posture
X
X
Common Risk Factors for Back
MSDs
• Force
• Frequency
• Posture
• Duration
• Environment
• Vibration
Back Injury Risk Factor Examples
o
o
o
o
Awkward Postures
Bending
Twisting
Reaching, etc.
Back Injury Risk Factor Examples
o
Lifting/Forceful Movements
o
o
o
o
o
Weight of load
Location (position of load w.r.t. worker)
Frequency
Stability
Coupling
Back Injury Risk Factor Examples
High Frequency and
Lifting Overhead
9
Back Injury Risk Factor Examples
Lifting or Lowering Floor Level
Lifting above Shoulder Height
Look for Clues – Use Assessment Tools
o
Sample Checklists
o
o
General Checklists
o
Kodak Ergonomics Checklist for
Material Handling
o
NIOSH Manual Material
Handling Checklist
Risk Factor Checklists
o
Hazard Evaluation Checklist for
Lifting, Carrying, Pushing or
Pulling (T.R. Waters)
o
Washington Awkward Postures
Checklist
o
REBA – Trunk/Legs
o
Analysis Tools
o
Websites
Look for Clues – General Checklists
Kodak’s Ergonomic Checklist for Material Handling
Source: Kodak’s Ergonomic Design for People at Work, as adapted in NIOSH
2007-131
Kodak’s Ergonomics Checklist for Material Handling
Condition
X if a Concern Comments
REPETITION
High-speed process line or work
presentation rates
Similar motions every few
seconds
Observed signs of fatigue
WORKSTATION DESIGN
Work surface too high or low
Location of materials promotes
reaching
Angle/orientation of containers
promotes non-neutral positions
Spacing between adjacent
transfer surfaces promotes
twisting
Obstructions prevent direct
access to load/unload points
Obstacles on floor prevent a
clear path of travel
Floor surfaces are uneven,
slippery, or sloping
Hoists or other power lifting
devices are needed but not
available
Kodak’s Ergonomics Checklist for Material Handling, cont.
LIFTING AND LOWERING
Heavy objects need to be
handled
Handling bulky or diffi cult-tograsp objects
Handling above the shoulders
or below the knees
Lifting to the side or
unbalanced lifting
Placing objects
accurately/precisely
Sudden, jerky movements
during handling
One-handed lifting
Long-duration exertions (static
work)
PUSHING/PULLING/CARRYING
Forceful pushing/pulling of
carts or equipment required
Brakes for stopping hand
carts/handling aids are
needed but not available
Carts or equipment design
promotes non- neutral
postures
Long-distance carrying (carts
not available)
Kodak’s Ergonomics Checklist for Material Handling, cont.
CONTAINERS/MATERIALS
Lack adequate handles or
gripping surfaces
Are unbalanced, unstable, or
contents shift
Obstructs leg movement when
being carried
OTHER
Inappropriate work techniques
used
Buildup of process material
/product increases worker
effort
Personal protective equipment
needed but not available/used
TOTAL SCORE (Optional)
To score, add up the
total number of Xs
identified.
Look for Clues – General Checklists
NIOSH Manual Material Handling (MMH) Checklist
Source: http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/97-117/eptbtr5f.html
NIOSH Manual Material Handling (MMH) Checklist
"No" responses indicate potential problem areas which should receive further investigation.
1. Are the weights of loads to be lifted judged acceptable by the workforce?
2. Are materials moved over minimum distances?
3. Is the distance between the object load and the body minimized?
4. Are walking surfaces
level?
wide enough?
clean and dry?
5. Are objects
easy to grasp?
stable?
able to be held without slipping?
6. Are there handholds on these objects?
7. When required, do gloves fit properly?
8. Is the proper footwear worn?
9. Is there enough room to maneuver?
10. Are mechanical aids used whenever possible?
11. Are working surfaces adjustable to the best handling heights?
12. Does material handling avoid
movements below knuckle height and above shoulder height?
static muscle loading?
sudden movements during handling?
twisting at the waist?
extended reaching?
13. Is help available for heavy or awkward lifts?
14. Are high rates of repetition avoided by
job rotation?
self-pacing?
sufficient pauses?
15. Are pushing or pulling forces reduced or eliminated?
16. Does the employee have an unobstructed view of handling the task?
17. Is there a preventive maintenance program for equipment?
18. Are workers trained in correct handling and lifting procedures?
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]yes
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
[ ]no
Look for Clues – Risk Factor Checklists
Hazard Evaluation Checklist for Lifting, Carrying, Pushing or Pulling
Source: T. R. Waters, “Manual Materials Handling”, in: Physical and Biological
Hazards of the Workplace (Second edition). Edited by P. Wald and G. Stave.
New York: John Wiley and Sons, 2002.
Hazard Evaluation Checklist for Lifting, Carrying, Pushing or Pulling
Risk Factors
1. General
1.1 Does the load handled exceed 50 lb.?
1.2 Is the object difficult to bring close to the body because of its
size, bulk, or shape?
1.3 Is the load hard to handle because it lacks handles or cutouts
for handles, or does it have slippery surfaces or sharp edges?
1.4 Is the footing unsafe? For example, are the floors slippery,
inclined, or uneven?
1.5 Does the task require fast movement, such as throwing,
swinging, or rapid walking?
1.6 Does the task require stressful body postures, such as
stooping to the fl oor, twisting, reaching overhead, or excessive
lateral bending?
1.7 Is most of the load handled by only one hand, arm, or
shoulder?
1.8 Does the task require working in extreme temperatures, with
noise, vibration, poor lighting, or airborne contaminants?
1.9 Does the task require working in a confi ned area?
2. Specific
2.1 Does lifting frequency exceed 5 lifts per minute?
2.2 Does the vertical lifting distance exceed 3 feet?
2.3 Do carries last longer than 1 minute?
2.4 Do tasks that require large sustained pushing or pulling
forces exceed 30 seconds duration?
2.5 Do extended reach static holding tasks exceed 1 minute?
YES
NO
Look for Clues – Risk Factor Checklists
Washington State Department of Labor and Industries – Hazard Zone
Checklist for Awkward Postures
Source: http://www.lni.wa.gov/Safety/Topics/Ergonomics/ServicesResources/Tool
s/
Washington State Department of Labor and Industries – Hazard Zone
Checklist for Awkward Postures
Calculator Exercise
Determine risk factors using checklist
Use Washington State “calculator to analyze
Lifting Jobs” to determine if the task is hazardous
Prioritize Jobs for Improvement
•
The frequency and severity of the risk factors you have
identified that may lead to injuries
•
The frequency and severity of complaints, symptoms, and/or
injuries
•
Technical and financial resources at your disposal
•
Ideas of workers for making improvements
•
Difficulty in implementing various improvements
•
Timeframe for making improvements
Make Improvements
Questions for selecting improvement options:
o
Reduce or eliminate most or all of the identified risk factors?
o
Add any new risk factors that have not been previously identified?
o
Be affordable for our organization (e.g., is there a simpler, less
expensive alternative that could be equally effective)?
o
Affect productivity, efficiency, or product quality?
o
Provide a temporary or permanent “fix”?
o
Be accepted by employees…will it affect employee morale?
o
Be able to be fully implemented (including training) in a
amount of time?
reasonable
Follow Up
Questions for evaluating improvements:
o
Reduced or eliminated fatigue, discomfort, symptoms, and/or
injuries?
o
Been accepted by workers?
o
Reduced or eliminated most or all of the risk factors?
o
Caused any new risk factors, hazards, or other problems?
o
Caused a decrease in productivity and efficiency?
o
Caused a decrease in product and service quality?
o
Been supported with the training needed to make it effective?
Improvements
• Easier Ways to Manually Lift, Lower, Fill, or
Empty Containers
– Management Guidelines for Safer Lifting
– Employee Guidelines for Safer Lifting
• Easier Ways to Manually Carry Containers
• Alternatives to Manual Handling of Individual
Containers
Specific Improvements
•
Plan the workflow to eliminate unnecessary lifts.
•
Organize the work so that the physical demands and work pace increase gradually.
•
Minimize the distances loads are lifted and lowered.
•
Position pallet loads of materials at a height that allows workers to lift and lower
within their power zone (Between 30 to 50 inches).
•
Avoid manually lifting or lowering loads to or from the floor.
•
Convert a carry to a push or pull
Review of Improvement Options
Improvement Options for Lifting
Lifting Device
Team Lift
Turntable
Improvement Options for Lifting
Adjustable Work
Platforms
Portable Stairs
Adjustable Work
Surfaces
Improvement Options for Awkward Postures
Remove Sides of
Receptacles
Add Handles to
Containers
Workstation Cut-Outs
Other Improvement Options
o
Washington State Ergonomics Idea Bank
o
http://www.lni.wa.gov/safety/topics/reducehazards/
ergobank/default.asp
Reference
Ergonomic Guidelines for Manual Material Handling
NIOSH 2007-131
http://
www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2007-131/
o
o
References
Musculoskeletal Disorders and Workplace Factors, NIOSH Publication No. 97Ergonomic Guidelines for Manual Material Handling, NIOSH Publication No.
141, 1997.
2007-131,
2007.
o Bureau of Labor Statistics Annual Survey, 1996.
o Washington State Department of Labor and Industries SHARP Technical Report 40-62002, 2002.
o Elements of Ergonomic Programs, NIOSH Publication No. 97-117, 1997.
o T. R. Waters, “Manual Materials Handling”, in: Physical and Biological Hazards of the
Workplace (Second edition). Edited by P. Wald and G. Stave. New York: John Wiley
and Sons,
2002.
o Kodak's Ergonomic Design for People at Work, Second Edition, Hoboken, NJ:
John Wiley &
Sons, Inc., 2007.
o Washington State Department of Labor and Industries Ergonomics Website:
o http://www.lni.wa.gov/safety/topics/ergonomics/default.asp
o Cornell University Ergonomics Website:
o http://ergo.human.cornell.edu
o University of Michigan 3D Static Strength Prediction Program Website:
o http://www.engin.umich.edu/dept/ioe/3DSSPP
o Ohio State University Biodynamics Website:
o http://biodynamics.osu.edu/research.html
Tier II – Analysis Tools
o
Quantitative Analysis Tools
o
NIOSH Lifting Equation
o
o
ACGIH Threshold Limit Values for Lifting
o
o
http://www.engin.umich.edu/dept/ioe/3DSSPP/
Ohio State Lumbar Motion Monitor
o
o
www.acgih.org/store
University of Michigan 3D Static Strength Prediction
Program
o
o
http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/94-110.html
http://biodynamics.osu.edu/research.html
Snook’s Psychophysical Tables
o
http://libertymmhtables.libertymutual.com/CM_LMTablesWeb/
taskSelection.do? action=initTaskSelection